# Ofwat blocks £6.5m in water bonuses and speeds up review of pay rules

> Nine water companies triggered Ofwat's bonus prohibition for 2025-26. The regulator is now bringing forward its review of the rules, citing concern that retention payments and base pay rises are undermining the ban.

Published 13 November 2026 by The Water Wire. Topic: Regulation & policy. Canonical: https://waterwire.co.uk/story/ofwat-blocks-bonuses-accelerates-pay-rules-review

Ofwat says nine water companies in England and Wales were barred from paying executive bonuses for 2025-26. It is also bringing forward its review of the pay rules, citing concern that retention payments and rises in base pay are weakening the ban. The figures come from the regulator's annual remuneration and governance assessment, published on 12 November. The Water Wire has not yet been able to review Ofwat's own documents, so this report draws on coverage by the [Guardian](https://www.aol.co.uk/articles/water-industry-bonus-ban-tightened-073012000.html) and [Water Magazine](https://www.watermagazine.co.uk/2026/11/13/ofwat-accelerates-executive-pay-rules-review-amid-concerns-over-retention-payments/).

## What we know

- **The nine companies.** According to the [Guardian](https://www.aol.co.uk/articles/water-industry-bonus-ban-tightened-073012000.html), seven of the nine bans related to environmental pollution. It named seven of the companies:
  - Thames Water
  - Yorkshire Water
  - Severn Trent Water
  - Southern Water
  - South West Water
  - Wessex Water
  - Dŵr Cymru
- **The amount blocked.** [Water Magazine](https://www.watermagazine.co.uk/2026/11/13/ofwat-accelerates-executive-pay-rules-review-amid-concerns-over-retention-payments/) reports that more than £6.5m in potential bonuses and other performance-related payments was prevented. The Guardian puts the figure at £6.5m.
- **Ofwat's reaction.** Helen Campbell, Ofwat's interim executive director for delivery, said it was "disappointing" that so many companies continue to trigger the rule through serious performance failures. She said £10m in payments has been blocked over two years.
- **Why the review is faster.** Ofwat said the growing use of fixed retention payments, and substantial increases in base pay without enough explanation, risk damaging public trust. It said they create a perception that companies are getting round the rule.
- **Retention schemes.** Water Magazine says six companies run executive retention schemes: Anglian Water, Northumbrian Water, Thames Water, United Utilities, Affinity Water and South East Water. It notes that the current rules do not treat these payments as performance-related pay.
- **Anglian Water.** Anglian was singled out over retention payments worth up to £800,000 for chief executive Mark Thurston, and will face increased monitoring of its governance. Ofwat said the payments could give the impression that Anglian had prioritised an award that would in practice replace prohibited pay.
- **Other potential retention payments** highlighted by Ofwat:
  - £1m for Thames Water's chief financial officer
  - £1.5m for Northumbrian Water chief executive Heidi Mottram
  - £1.7m for United Utilities chief executive Louise Beardmore

## What others are reporting

The [Guardian](https://www.aol.co.uk/articles/water-industry-bonus-ban-tightened-073012000.html) reports several further points:

- Thames Water paid chief executive Chris Weston a previously deferred bonus of £99,000 during the year. Ofwat said Thames's future owners, not customers, must bear that cost.
- South East Water was not subject to the ban. Ofwat said its shareholders would have to fund any future bonuses after large supply failures.
- Ofwat criticised how little pay information South Staffs Water reported.
- Environment secretary Angela Eagle said "failure doesn't pay, whatever name the payment goes by". She said she wanted loopholes closed.

## Background

The government introduced the bonus ban the previous year amid public anger over sewage pollution, the [Guardian](https://www.aol.co.uk/articles/water-industry-bonus-ban-tightened-073012000.html) reports. It adds that its own analysis found water bosses' pay rose over the past two years despite the ban. Campaigners and opposition politicians argue that companies get round it through payments that are not classed as performance-related.

## What to watch

- The call for evidence, which [Water Magazine](https://www.watermagazine.co.uk/2026/11/13/ofwat-accelerates-executive-pay-rules-review-amid-concerns-over-retention-payments/) says was published alongside the assessment. Its deadline and the review timetable have not been confirmed.
- Whether the review brings retention payments or base pay increases within the prohibition.
- Ofwat's increased monitoring of Anglian Water's governance.
- Responses from the companies named.

The headline number shows the ban is biting. The more significant development is Ofwat's admission that the rule's design leaves gaps.

Fixed retention awards fall outside the definition of performance-related pay. Ofwat has highlighted potential payments of up to £1.7m to individual chief executives, well above the deferred bonus it objected to at Thames. That gives the regulator a clear case for widening the scope, and the environment secretary has signalled political backing.

The harder question is where to draw the line. Boards argue they need to retain leaders through turnaround and heavy investment. Ofwat, by contrast, frames the issue as public trust and asks companies to explain pay rises properly.

A definition broad enough to capture retention awards and unexplained base-pay increases will be harder to apply mechanically. It may push the regulator towards case-by-case judgement on governance, as it is now doing with Anglian.

Until the call for evidence closes, the scope and timing of any change remain open.

## Sources

- [Guardian (via AOL) — Water industry bonus ban tightened](https://www.aol.co.uk/articles/water-industry-bonus-ban-tightened-073012000.html)
- [Water Magazine — Ofwat accelerates executive pay rules review](https://www.watermagazine.co.uk/2026/11/13/ofwat-accelerates-executive-pay-rules-review-amid-concerns-over-retention-payments/)
- [watermagazine.co.uk](https://www.watermagazine.co.uk/2026/11/12/6-5m-in-bonuses-blocked-as-nine-water-companies-trigger-ofwats-rule/)
