# Tribunal cuts Southern Water's Herne Bay sewage penalty from £1m to £525,000

> A tribunal has reduced the Environment Agency's £1m variable monetary penalty on Southern Water to £525,000. It upheld the regulator's findings on culpability and harm, in an early test of the civil penalty regime.

Published 18 November 2026 by The Water Wire. Topic: Regulation & policy. Canonical: https://waterwire.co.uk/story/tribunal-cuts-southern-water-herne-bay-sewage-penalty

A First-tier Tribunal has reduced a £1m variable monetary penalty (VMP) imposed by the Environment Agency on Southern Water to £525,000. The penalty followed a sewage discharge near Herne Bay in March 2024. According to [Solicitors Journal](https://www.solicitorsjournal.com/sjarticle/southern-water-v-environment-agency-tribunal-nearly-halves-1m-herne-bay-sewage-penalty), the tribunal upheld the EA's assessment of culpability and harm but disagreed with how the figure was reached.

## What we know

The case is Southern Water Services Limited v The Environment Agency [2026] UKFTT 1562 (GRC). The panel was chaired by Judge O'Connor, Chamber President. [Solicitors Journal](https://www.solicitorsjournal.com/sjarticle/southern-water-v-environment-agency-tribunal-nearly-halves-1m-herne-bay-sewage-penalty) reported the main points of the decision.

- **The incident:** on 23 March 2024 a pressurised PVC rising main split. Untreated sewage flowed via highway gullies into the Bishopstone Glen watercourse, which runs about 300m to the sea. The coastline carries several conservation designations and was then a designated bathing water. The discharge lasted at least seven hours.
- **Water quality:** E. coli measured 3.3 million cfu per 100ml at the point of discharge. Ammonia reached levels toxic to aquatic life, although no dead fish or invertebrates were found.
- **Southern Water's case:** the company accepted the offence. It argued that culpability was low, that harm was Category 3 and that the right penalty was £140,000.
- **Culpability:** the tribunal found the company negligent. The same main had burst in December 2022. The operational continuity plan dated from 2016 and was silent on the pipework needed for over-pumping. Only 40 of the 80 metres required arrived on the day, and over-pumping took about nine hours to get running. The tribunal rejected the argument that tanker shortages were the real constraint.
- **Harm:** the tribunal placed harm in Category 2. It found significant effects on water quality and on bathing amenity, and said it was not material that the incident fell outside the bathing season.

The tribunal built up the penalty in stages:

1. The starting point was £140,000.
2. It raised this to £350,000 to reflect turnover of about £992m.
3. It reduced this to £300,000 because the harm was short-lived.
4. It increased the figure to £700,000 because of 174 previous convictions dating back to 1990, which it treated as an exceptionally serious aggravating factor.
5. It applied a one-quarter reduction for prompt self-reporting and cooperation, giving £525,000. Guilty-plea credit does not apply to VMPs.

## Background

VMPs are a civil alternative to prosecution. They apply to offences committed in England on or after 1 December 2023. This appeal was brought under Schedule 26A to the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2016. The tribunal reheard the case in full and applied the EA's 12-step enforcement policy and the Sentencing Council guideline afresh. Southern Water bore the burden of proof, [Solicitors Journal](https://www.solicitorsjournal.com/sjarticle/southern-water-v-environment-agency-tribunal-nearly-halves-1m-herne-bay-sewage-penalty) reported.

The Water Wire has not seen the decision itself, or any statement from Southern Water or the EA.

## What to watch

- Whether the EA changes how it calculates VMPs after this ruling.
- Whether other companies appeal VMPs, given that the tribunal rehears cases in full.
- Any response from Southern Water or the EA.

For the Environment Agency, the ruling is mixed. The tribunal endorsed its findings that Southern Water was negligent and that the harm was Category 2. It still nearly halved the penalty, despite adding a large uplift for 174 previous convictions. Because the tribunal reheard the case in full, the EA's own calculations carry limited weight on appeal. The guideline arithmetic, from starting point through adjustments for turnover and record, will decide outcomes. For companies, the culpability findings are the sharper lesson. A repeat burst on the same main, a continuity plan untouched since 2016 and half the needed pipework on site were enough for negligence. The plan was updated only in January 2026. VMPs are meant to offer quicker, proportionate enforcement than prosecution. It is unresolved whether appeals like this will narrow the gap between the penalties the regulator proposes and those that stand. The tribunal's reasoning on turnover and previous convictions is likely to be scrutinised.

## Sources

- [Solicitors Journal — Southern Water v Environment Agency: tribunal nearly halves £1m Herne Bay sewage penalty](https://www.solicitorsjournal.com/sjarticle/southern-water-v-environment-agency-tribunal-nearly-halves-1m-herne-bay-sewage-penalty)
